By Jivesh Jha–
At a time when some political parties in Nepal’s Madhes, claiming to
represent the Madheshis and Tharu ethnic minorities, have termed Nepal’s
new constitution not broad-based and have expressed concern that some
of the provisions would politically marginalize them, this comparative
study of the constitutional provisions of Nepal and India reveals that
Nepal’s constitution is more progressive than the latter’s.
Madheshi parties are leading an agitation over the new constitution
from since the first draft was endorsed by the Constituent Assembly in
July, arguing that “Hill elites” have offered little for them in the new
constitution. The claims of agitating groups stand valid in terms of
citizenship, delineation of electoral constituencies, and affirmative
action provisions, which appear to be discriminatory and ambiguous. But
on other key issues, Nepal’s new constitution leaves India’s far behind.
The preamble of any constitution is regarded as the window from where
to look into the overall silhouette of the state. “Though the preamble
of constitution of Nepali (CON) appears to be lengthy, it gives a
broader spectrum. Had it been constrained in short, it would not have
given clear objectives of the legislation in a manner as it’s giving,”
appreciates Prashant Chauhan, who is the Associate Professor of
Constitutional Law in Uttarakhand Technical University (UTU), Dehradun.
He further argues that the CON is written in simple and understandable
language.
“In India, Constitution of India (COI) is regarded as lawyer’s
paradise; the words are so technical that an ordinary person cannot
understand completely. However, no such problem with CON,” argues
Chauhan. Further, the preamble clearly suggests that Nepalis are
sovereign and state powers inherent in them.
While the leaders failing to understand the cultural relations of
Madheshis across the border, they put unreasonable restriction on the
means of acquiring the citizenship by descent, under Article (U/A)
11(3), which provisions that in order to get a citizenship by descent,
the offspring’s both “father and mother should hold citizenship by
descent.”
The position is different in case of COI. In India, an offspring gets
citizenship by descent provided any of the “father or mother” is an
Indian citizen.
Further, there is no provision for naturalized
citizenship in India. Under the provisions of COI, it also provides any
person to acquire citizenship who was born within the territory of India
irrespective of his/her parents’ nationality. Nevertheless, CON does
not offer the right to acquire citizenship by birth.
“The Article 11(3) has an overriding effect on A-11(2) & A-11(6).
The clause 3 of A-11 appears to be more conflicting and adversely
affecting the interest of the child in which he had no role to play.
After the enforcement of this constitution, the CON seems to deface a
large chunk of people who have established matrimonial relations with
foreign nationals,” further observes Chauhan.
“In Nepal, the constitution has been drafted on the wisdom of big
four players—Nepali Congress, UML, RPP and UCPN (Maoist). They have
already shown their racial tilt by excluding a section of people’s
interest & rights. The notion of inclusion & federalism has been
put under suspended animation from the very date of enforcement of this
constitution as they [big four parties] have beautifully succeeded in
achieving their goal of making Madheshis further marginalized,” claims
Aatmaram Prasad Shah, former Lawmaker of Constituent Assembly-I.
Noted, unlike India, A-289 bars a naturalized citizen to hold any vital government offices.
However, these types of provisions have not been embodied in COI in both spirit and letter.
Regarding the fundamental rights (FR), right to property is a legal
right in India while CON envisages it as a FR. Similarly, the A-18 of
CON is similar in nature as that of A-14 of COI where it talks about
equality before law and equal protection before law.
In what is being seen as a novel concept before the world, the CON
has envisaged right to communication, Under Article (U/A)-19, which
empowers people with complete freedom for the information disseminating
outlets. “However, the COI provisions for freedom of speech &
expression U/A-19 (1)(a) which has a wider spectrum, covers entire
rights falling under the ambit of freedom of information &
communication. It’s a noble concept,” says Dr JN Singh, faculty of
Constitutional Law in UTU, Dehradun.
Citing the imperfection of drafting, Dr Singh argues that the right
to freedom could cover multiple aspects.
“There was no need to discuss
each and every right under separate heads even as it falls under the
ambit of a common freedom. For example, there was no need to deal right
of women, right of Dalit, right of senior citizen, right of children
under different Articles, it would have offered a broader spectrum had
the parliament clubbed these provisions into one,” he further adds.
However, he was quick to add that A-30 to 44 appears like government
policies than the basic essentials of constitution.
Meanwhile, amid moving a step ahead than the COI, the CON has ensured
right of compensation for the victims of crime as a FR, U/A-21.
“However, in India, this provision was inserted through judicial
pronouncements. Nepali parliament was quick to bestow the emphasis on
the right to compensation from the very initial stage of enforcement of
the constitution which is a welcoming move,” says Mrs. Devika Singh
Rana, who is the Associate Professor of Criminal Law at UTU.
Ensuring zero tolerance against the violence against women, the CON
has envisaged extensive rights for women U/A-38 as a FR. However, there
leaves no any provision for women specifically made as a matter of FR in
COI. “The right for women envisaged under CON is really welcoming. The
equal right on property & family affairs for women was realized by
Indian legal system in latter stage, i.e. from 2005. As a faculty of
law, what I believe that Nepal is a step ahead than India regarding
ensuring the right of women as a matter of FR. The A-38(5) provides
positive discrimination for the upliftment of women which has no
colliding effect with right to equality, A-18 and beyond any reasonable
doubt its’ really a magnificent provision with natural import,” proudly
says Rana.
Expressing deep appreciation to the Nepali parliament, she further
opines that the provision of free legal aid has been ensured as a matter
of FR by CON from the very date of enforcement, which is another
welcoming move. “In India, the legislature and judiciary realized it in
latter stage and inserted through amendment. However, CON incorporated
it from the very beginning which is rightly a paradigm shift,” observes
Rana.
Maintaining a similar tune, much-acclaimed jurist Professor Dr
Anirudh Prasad, who is currently associated with Rajiv Gandhi National
University of Law, Patiala, Punjab, also argues that Nepal is a more
progressive than India when it comes to ensure the rights of women in
constitution.
“The right of women is reserved in India through A-15(3),
A-16(4) and 21. Moreover, their rights were guaranteed through judicial
interpretation. However, the rights of women have been ensured through
legislation at earlier stage proves that Nepal carrying more progressive
approach,” insists Dr Prasad.
Meanwhile, the right to information is nowhere mentioned under the
ambit of FR in COI. However, CON U/A-27 ensures that it would the
obligation of the state to ensure right of information (RTI) for every
citizen as a matter of FR. However, a separate Act of RTI Act deals with
this right in India. It was realized by the Indian legislature in very
latter stage.
The protection of right to life and personal liberty except the
procedure established by law is embodied U/A-21 of COI which has the
widest interpretation. The provisions dealing with A-(28-44) of CON are
covered by a solo A-21 of COI,” adds Professor Chauhan.
So far the implementation of FR is concerned, constitutional remedy
is envisaged U/A-46 to be read with A-133 or A-144 of CON. However,
these provisions differ from COI. The writ petition is entertained by
Supreme Court (SC) only on the violation of FR, embodied U/A-32 of COI.
Further, for the purpose of ensuring all other legal rights, including
FR, the High Court (HC) is empowered to entertain writ, U/A-226, COI.
Nevertheless, in case of Nepal, the HC & SC both are empowered to
entertain the writs on the violation of all other constitutional &
legal rights, including FR.
Moreover, the transferability of cases is concerned from one HC to
another, the provisions of the both countries stands on a similar
footing.
Even as the CON adopts that the state would have no religion as it
has adopted secularism on all hands, the single provision of A-26 to
deal with the notion has narrowed the spectrum. In India, secularism has
been overwhelmingly accepted and covered U/A (25-30), COI. The CON
nowhere ensures right to allow religious instructions or lessons through
educational curricula or through religious minority institutions, while
A-28, COI ensures the same right as a matter of FR.
Under the legal academics, the law of equity is often regarding as of
the greatest significance. Following this doctrine of equity, CON
ensures distribution of revenue between center and state in equitable
nature. However, COI empowers extensive power on Union parliament. As
COI provides extensive power to Union by ruling out the doctrine of
equity in many cases, it’s often called a quasi-federal state.
More, regarding the qualification of President, minimum age of
eligibility stands at 45 in case of Nepal while in case of India, its
35. The same person can be elected in any number of times as president
in India while CON follows US system of qualification of president where
there is restriction for not more than two terms.
However, the matter of taking of oath of office and tendering resignation appears to be similar in both countries.
Regarding electoral constituencies, A-286 (12) of CON provides for
delineation of electoral constituencies in every 20 years. However, COI
simply says parliament may from time to time make provisions with
respect to all matters in connection with election. Further, the CON
provides while delineating electoral constituencies, population and
geography both will be taken into account whereas COI envisages only
population to be basis for delineating constituencies. There are nine
states where population density is lower, and for them one seat each is
allocated for Upper House at Union whereas there are four such states
blessed with one seat each for House of people at Union parliament. “The
preamble of our constitution clearly suggests that the sovereignty is
vested on people and so the population has been taken a single base for
delineation of electoral constituencies,” says Abhiranjan Dixit, Jurist
& Associate Professor of Constitutional Law at Apeejay Satya
University.
However, widely admired commentator of constitutional law in India,
Dr Anirudh Prasad, who has authored scores of books on Law, is of the
opinion that the move of Nepal to take the population and geography both
into account while delineating electoral constituencies is welcoming
and it should be taken positively. “As Nepal has a different
socio-cultural and other ground reality than that of India, the move of
taking even geography into account is welcoming. In some of the Hill
constituencies, there might be very less density of electorates;
however, it does not mean that they should not be represented. It’s a
good gesture for strengthening a democratic set up,” maintains Dr
Prasad, who is also the Dean of Student welfare at RGNLU, Patiala.
While talking about state legislature, in India its bicameral while
in Nepal it’s unicameral. Of 29 states, seven states in India having
bicameral provincial legislature. Similarly, there are three Lists in
both of countries on which center and/or state can enact laws.
Further, under the umbrella of welfare policies of the state, the
Directive Principle of State Policy (DPSP) has been envisaged under
part-IV of CON and COI as well. The COI used the word—“Social
welfare”—as the object of DPSP while for the same notion CON wished to
use the word—“Public Welfare”. However, both neighboring countries
firmly believe that the DPSP is not enforceable in any court of law.
“It’s beyond any iota of doubt that the spectrum of DPSP has been
narrowed down by the CON with the insert of the word ‘public welfare’
against ‘social welfare’. The ambit of social welfare is much wider. The
doctrine of social welfare ensures a wider guiding principle for
mainstreaming the weaker section of society,” further adds Dr Prasad.
While for bringing marginalized groups into mainstream, the CON
envisages “principle of inclusion” in all state structure whereas for
achieving the same goal Indian constitution adopts “principle of
proportional representation.” However, the CON has not clarified the
manner in which principle would be followed, leaving a scope of
ambiguity.
The judiciary which till now has been accepted on all hands as the
strongest pillar of democracy is likely to be snowed under unprecedented
problems followed by political intervention. The CON, U/A-153 provides
for the formation of Judicial Council where law minister is given a
berth with teeth. However, the COI ensures no room for political
intervention in appointment & removal of judges of higher judiciary.
In India, a collegiums of Apex Court judges holds authority in
appointment and removal of judges of higher judiciary where legislature
has no role to play whereas Judicial council holds responsibility for
the same task in Nepal, which prepares a safe ground for political
intervention as the law minister is given a welcoming berth in the said
council.
“Noted, the Union parliament came up with National Judicial
Appointment Commission Act in the similar fashion as envisaged U/A-153
of CON which faced a knee-jerk reaction by the judiciary on the ground
that the said Act posed a serious concern over the independency of
judiciary alone and the Act was declared unconstitutional by SC
recently. Such provision would certainly hamper the independency of
judiciary,” argues Dr Sharafat Ali, Jurist-cum-Senior Professor of
Constitutional Law at UTU.
Further, the SC of Nepal shall only be Court of Record whereas in
case of India the HC & SC both. Like India, the constitution is
supreme in Nepal—unlike British law where parliament is supreme.
“The Nepali parliament’s approach to not to take HC as Court of
Record would certainly make HC weaker as it would not be entitled to
punish for the contempt of court and moreover their decisions will not
be binding in nature,” heralds Dr Prasad, while citing the drawback of
this provision.
There appears ambiguity when we interpret the provisions of
citizenship. Moreover, the constitution has failed to provide a broader
picture on the need of delineation of electoral constituencies on the basis of geography and people. And, the
constitution has not clarified the manner in which the principle of
inclusion would be adopted for mainstreaming the marginalized sections
of society into state affairs.
Moreover, the attempt of making only SC to be Court of Record would
ultimately make judiciary weak, and formation of Judicial and Constitutional Council for
appointment & removal of judges, which prepares a safe invitation of
political intervention.
- Progressive Provisions—a step ahead than India:
Similarly, in some of provisions, like free legal aid as FR, right to
women as FR, right to information & communication as FR, doctrine
of equity to be followed in case of distribution of revenue, the same
person can be elected as president for maximum two terms like USA,
provincial legislature unicameral, right of compensation for victim of
crime, the HC & SC both are entitled to entertain the writs on
violation of both FR and other legal rights and among other noteworthy
provisions prove that Nepal is a step ahead than the current
constitution of India.
However, are we really ahead? The answer would come in affirmative
sense only when we come victorious to realize the dreams of preamble in
both words and actions.
Comparison at a glance:
- India: No naturalized citizenship, citizenship even on the ground of birth
- Nepal: Citizenship be descent and by naturalized mode, where
naturalized citizens are barred to vital government offices, including that of President, governor.
- Nepal: Father & mother both citizen then only citizen by descent
- India: Any of parents citizen, offspring to get citizenship by descent
- Nepal: right to compensation for victim of crime as FR from beginning stage
- India: compensation right realized at latter stage through amendments
- Nepal: free legal aid as a matter of FR
- India: free legal aid not as FR, but legal right turned into a FR by judicial interpretation
- Nepal: Right of Women is FR, wider sense
- India: no specifically mentioned under FR, narrower sense
- Nepal: Right to information as FR
- India: not enlisted under FR, governed by RTI Act
- ….
- Nepal: SC/HC can entertain writs on violation of legal right as well as FR
- India: SC entertains writs only on violation of FR, HC on both legal plus FR
- …
- Nepal: Public welfare as object of DPSP
- India: Social welfare as object of DPSP
- ..
- Nepal: SC to be only Court of Record
- India: HC & SC both as Court of Record
- ..
- Nepal: Doctrine of Equity applicable on distribution of revenue between state & centre
- India: No equity. Union has extensive power
- ..
Nepal: Constituency delineation in every 20 years, population & geography to be basis
India: delineation may from time to time by Union, population only basis
- ..
- Nepal: Minimum age 45 for becoming President
- ..
- Nepal: Provincial legislature unicameral
- India: Bicameral, but only in seven states
- ..
- Nepal: Judicial Council, where law minister a component part, for appointment, removal of judges
- India: Collegiums of SC judges, no role of politics
- ..
- Nepal: Like India, constitution is supreme
- England: Parliament is supreme.